Brick Street Chocolate Cupcakes: everything you love about the decadent Famous Brick Street Chocolate Cake, but in cupcake form. Rich, dense chocolate cupcakes with thick, chocolate ganache frosting. If you love the Brick Street Chocolate Cake, you’ll adore these incredible cupcakes. This recipe makes two dozen regular size cupcakes. (The cupcakes you see here are not mini cupcakes.)
For some time I’ve been wanting to adapt the original Brick Street Chocolate Cake recipe to make cupcakes. Some of you have requested it too. The truth is, one day months ago I tried it on the fly and it was somewhat of a disaster. I overfilled the cups and the batter spilled over the edges of the muffin tin during baking, resulting in a smoking oven mess. The cupcake edges were overdone and the centers didn’t cook through. Disaster with a capital D!
Yesterday I set aside the entire day to test and experiment with the original recipe to create these Brick Street Chocolate Cupcakes. I’m so glad I did, because the result is the gorgeous chocolate cupcakes you see here. Dense, chocolatey and every bit as spectacular as the original cake, these cupcakes are frosted with thick chocolate ganache.
Some of you know about my four boys. My littlest is Hudson. He’s six and has Down syndrome. He has lots of love in his little heart but few words to express it. There are many wonderful people who help our family navigate the terms ‘special needs’ and ‘disability’. I’ve loved writing about Hudson’s wonderful experiences on his little yellow school bus through the years.
This year he once again has wonderful bus drivers and helpers. A team of two special people bring Hudson home on the little yellow Easter Seals school bus each weekday afternoon. As Hudson gets off the bus, the white-haired man and his helper often say things to me like: “Hudson’s so funny, he has such a great sense of humor.” “Hudson got us laughing so hard today.” “He loves watching out the windows, he doesn’t miss a beat.” “Hudson’s a doll, wish we had ten of him riding on our bus.”
Imagine how precious words like these are to a mom like me with a little boy who can’t tell me one detail about his day, let alone about the bus ride home. It’s a gift to hear just a smidge about his day, especially since he doesn’t have the words to tell me himself. To know he’s loved and appreciated for the special little person he is.
So yesterday when I finished photographing these cupcakes, it was nearly time for Hudson to arrive home from school. I scrambled to find the leftover little white cupcake boxes in the back of the pantry and the red and white striped kitchen twine. I boxed up fresh Brick Street Chocolate Cupcakes for both the bus driver and his assistant. I don’t even know their names, but it was my tiny way of saying thank you for all the kindness they show my little Hudson each day.
When the little yellow school bus arrived, I was waiting at the end of the driveway with the cupcakes in the twine-wrapped boxes. I exchanged the boxes for Hudson and told the driver I needed some taste testers today. Could they help?
The funny thing is, those two have no idea what I do at home all day every day. For all they know I sit around eating bon-bons and watching soaps. (For the record: I don’t.) And they’d just hit the jackpot with these cupcakes, and didn’t know it yet. Funny. And it made me smile thinking about it.
So today, the day after I gave them the cupcakes, Hudson got off the bus and there were smiles all around. The bus driver mentioned they’d need another dozen cupcakes or so to round out the taste testing. Just to be sure and all.
“Valentine’s Day is just around the corner,” I said. “Maybe Cupid will bring you some.”
Baking Tips:
- This recipe makes two dozen full-size cupcakes. Several have asked if they are mini cupcakes. They are not. I got the full size paper muffin liners at the Dollar Store!)
- Directions are included for baking these cupcakes in a convection or regular (conventional) oven.
- Bake in a convection oven for 16 minutes at 350° or until a cake tester comes out clean.
- Bake in a conventional (regular) oven for 8 minutes at 350°, turn the oven down to 325° and bake an additional 8 minutes or until a cake tester comes out clean.
- Use cupcake liners for this recipe.
- This recipe makes 2 dozen cupcakes. Please don’t overfill the cups to make fewer, larger cupcakes. The batter will spill over the edges during the last half of the baking time, making a mess in your oven and yielding cupcakes with overcooked edges and undercooked centers.
Frosting Tips:
- Frost the cupcakes right after making the ganache – while it’s still warm. Ganache has a lot of melted butter in it and hardens as it cools. The ganache will be difficult to spread when it’s completely cool. Slightly re-warm the ganache in the microwave or on the stovetop to make it spreadable if you need to make it ahead.
- Spread the ganache with a knife, or use a pastry bag and tip as I did.
- I used a plastic pastry bag and the jumbo No. 2110 (1M) open star decorating tip by Wilton on the cupcakes pictured here.
Brick Street Chocolate Cupcakes
Ingredients
Cupcakes:
- 1 1/3 cups sugar
- 2/3 cup butter room temperature
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 2 large eggs
- 1 2/3 cups cake flour
- 2/3 cup baking cocoa
- 1 1/2 teaspoons baking soda
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 1/3 cup instant chocolate pudding mix not made into pudding, just the dry mix
- 1 1/2 cups buttermilk
- 2/3 cup chocolate chips or mini chocolate chips
Chocolate Ganache Frosting:
- 4.5 ounces unsweetened baking chocolate
- 6 tablespoons butter
- 6 tablespoons milk
- 3 1/2 cups powdered sugar
- 3 teaspoons pure vanilla extract
Instructions
Cupcakes:
- Preheat regular, conventional oven to 350°.
- Beat sugar, butter & vanilla in large bowl.
- Beat in eggs.
- Mix in cake flour, baking cocoa, soda, salt, chocolate pudding and buttermilk.
- Stir in semi-sweet chocolate chips.
- Place cupcake papers in muffin tins.
- Drop batter - a generous tablespoon and a half for each cupcake - into paper lined muffin tins, filling muffin cups about halfway.
- (Do not overfill or batter will spill over into your oven.)
- This recipe makes 24 cupcakes.
- CONVENTIONAL Oven: Bake in a 350° conventional oven for 8 minutes. Turn oven down to 325° and bake an additional 8 minutes (or until cake tester in the middle comes out clean.)
- CONVECTION Oven: Bake in a 350° convection oven for 16 minutes or until cake tester in the middle comes out clean.
Chocolate Ganache Frosting
- In a microwave safe bowl or a saucepan on the stovetop, melt butter and chocolate together.
- Whisk until thoroughly mixed.
- Whisk in milk and vanilla extract.
- With electric hand mixer, beat in powdered sugar.
- Frost cupcakes while ganache is still warm, using a pastry bag and tip (I used a plastic pastry bag and the jumbo No. 2110 (1M) open star decorating tip by Wilton) or spread with a knife.
- If you make the frosting ahead, keep it tightly covered. Then warm ganache slightly on the stovetop or in the microwave to make it spreadable again.
You may also like: Brick Street Chocolate Cake
Adina says
What a nice post you wrote, I read every word of it. And I think I will bake these amazing cupcakes today, I have to say thank you to someone as well. Plus that we have so many
leftover chocolate Santas. ?
Summer says
What kind of liners are these?
Allie says
Hi Summer – Don’t have a name for you, but I got them at the dollar store. They are paper – wasn’t sure if they would work – but they were perfect!
Andy says
Sorry about replying on this comment, has nothing to do with it. Just a little rushed and I’m posting on the first available spot. Wondering how important it is to use liners? Will it be a disaster if I don’t?
Allie says
Hmm…I have only done it with liners and they are pretty dense, heavy cupcakes. I think I would have to say I would definitely recommend liners. Foil liners work well. Good luck Andy, and if you decide to forge ahead without the liners, would be so grateful if you’d comment back and let everyone if it worked. Thank you and happy baking, so glad you dropped by. Merry Christmas!
Adina says
Hi Allie. I actually made the cupcakes last week and we all loved them . I only had to substitute the cake flour, because we don’t get that here. I used the chocolate santas instead of chocolate chips. Thank you for the recipe!
Allie says
Oh I’m SO glad Adina, thanks for letting me know. That was a great way to use up those chocolate Santas too. Have a wonderful week! XO
Aunt Pinkie says
These cupcakes look deliciously decadent!
Lori says
Love this post! Combining your flair for seeing and poignantly expressing the simple (important) things in life that fly by many of us, with another fabulous recipe!
Allie says
Thanks for the kind words Lori. (I teared up.) XO
Shashi at RunninSrilankan says
I so so love hearing stories of when kindness and love meet up with even more kindness and love. Allie, Hudson’s bus driver and assistant are such gems – but, so are you, kind friend. What a sweet and kind gesture – I bet they were tickled pink – or should I say tickled chocolate? 🙂
I remember your decadent Brick Street Cake – it inspired me to drive up to Brick Street Cafe last year – and now these cupcakes are making me wanna drive upto your neck of the woods – they sound wonderful! P.S. – if you are looking for taste-testers – am pretty good in that department (gotta toot my own horn sometime – eh? )
I hope your week is wonderful, my friend. xo
Rosemary says
I think I’ll try these for a wedding shower this weekend! I told my sister-on-law she had to have “something” chocolate! Why just something chocolate? Why not individidual chocolate deliciousness!!
Thanks, Allie!
Allie says
Thanks Rosemary – hope they are a big hit – love to all! (And belated Happy 16th to Bradley!)
Heather Kinnaird says
my chocolate lovers are going to flip for these
Tracy says
Oh……I have been waiting for this post? For the recipe that is. Forgot about the wonderful stories that come with your posts. Your loving outlook and kindness always touches my heart, my friend!! I do love hearing about Hudson and all the important people in his life. As I’ve said before…. Your boys are so very lucky to have you as their mom? These cupcakes look unbelievable! Can’t wait to make these!!! Thank you?
Susie Mandel says
Thank you for the Allie’s Test Kitchen doing all the hard work in bringing this recipe! (I think my oven looks like it was used in some testing, though.) Looking forward to trying these!! I think with the pounds I’ve lost, I need to reward myself–just try not to go overboard!
Always love your stories, and I know your cupcakes brightened Hudson’s helpers in a big way. 🙂
Allie says
Thank you Susie, hope you enjoy these cupcakes my friend. “Allie’s Test Kitchen.” Has a ring to it. My next blog name. Hee hee. Have a great week Susie!
Cynthia | What A Girl Eats says
Oh, you know how I love your brick street cake…I love these bite-sized cupcakes!
Denise Q. says
These cupcakes look amazing!
Allie says
Thank you Denise!
Catherine says
Dear Allie, I loved that chocolate cake when you posted it…these little gems are just as stunning. That gorgeous ganache frosting is calling to me!
The kindness of strangers can be overwhelming and there is no better way to express our appreciation than with a homemade gift – especially one baked with love. Such a sweet story…hugs to you and Hudson dear. xoxo, Catherine
Coleen @ The Redhead Baker says
If I made these, they would not get frosted, because the ganache would straight from the bowl to my mouth. Love everything about these!
Dot says
Oh Allie, they look sooo yummy!
Thank you for sharing!
Patricia @ Grab a Plate says
I love how sweet this is– the kindness in all your hearts, more so than these beautiful cupcakes! What a great story that proves simple gestures make big impacts. I love how fabulous and chocolaty these look – yum!
Jennifer @NourishedSimply says
I wonderful that sweet Hudson has such special people to help him. I bet they loved these cupcakes. Can’t wait to try them. I can’t resist chocolate let alone anything with ganache!
Cheyanne @ No Spoon Necessary says
I’ve never heard of Brick Street, so I have zero idea what their chocolate cake looks like, but these cupcakes look to die for girlfriend! I’d say all of your experimentation was totally worth it Allie, because these cupcakes look absolutely perfect! Boy is a chocoholic, so I KNOW he’d die over these!! I’m going to have to make these for him over the weekend! I hope the week is treating you well, dear! Cheers! xoxo
Carina says
Dear Allie, wonderful stories about the bus. What a kind gesture to give them those cupcakes, I’m sure that you made their day. Now, I have to say that these cupcakes look AMAZING. Wow. It seems your day of experimentation was a resounding success! (And well worth the learning experience provided by that first attempt ?). I bet your family loved sampling the results! Have a great rest of the week! Xoxo
Judy R says
Made these cupcakes this morning and am very disappointed in the way they came out….they all sunk and look horrible.
Allie says
Hey Judy – hate to hear they didn’t come out for you, so frustrating. If you want to trouble shoot, I’m game. I know oven temps can vary pretty significantly and since the baking times for cupcakes is so short anyway — if they come out of the oven even just a little early and are still not fully cooked in the center – they can easily fall. When I baked mine, I made a batch in the convection oven and the other in the regular oven and had good results both ways. Again – sorry to hear they weren’t a success. I hope at least they tasted good.
Rita says
Allie, you are amazing! I work with children with special needs and I must say, it is the most rewarding job one could have. I’ve made the cake and it turned out perfect! Best cake we’ve ever had. Thank you! I don’t have mini pans do you have any suggestions on regular size muffins pans? I assume double the recipe and cook longer.?
Allie says
Hi Rita – thank you so much. We are SO grateful for very special people like you who work with our children. I often write about the wonderful people in our life that help Hudson and our family. Here is a post you might enjoy: http://throughherlookingglass.com/special-place-in-heaven/ So glad you like the cake. Although the pictures may be deceiving, these are actually full size cupcakes. I bought these full size paper muffin liners at the Dollar store – but without a reference point, they do look like minis. So the recipe you see here yields two dozen full size cupcakes. I hope you enjoy!
Paige says
If I wanted to make these coffee/mocha flavored, how should I go about that? I’ve parsed through a lot of mocha cupcake recipes but I want them to be as dense and moist as these look, and I’m unsure of how to add the coffee/espresso powder combo that they usually call for without unbalancing the texture. What amounts do you recommend and when should I add them?
Anu - My Ginger Garlic Kitchen says
Such a wonderfully written post, Allie. So happy to know that Hudson has really nice people to help him. I haven’t had Brick Street cupcakes, but I love chocolate like anything, so I can tell I would love these. Chocolate is a win in my dictionary. Can’t wait to try them to please myself. 🙂
Shelly says
These look so good! If I want to make them for a party the day ahead, do they need to be refrigerated or do they do ok sitting out?
Allie says
Hi Shelly – Thanks – I left mine out. But I think the frosting looks better fresher. So I made the cupcakes the day ahead, but made the frosting the day of the party. They are a dense chocolate cupcake, very much like the Brick Street Chocolate Cake, FYI. Hope you love them!
Gail says
These were delicious, and I will make them again. But after piping it on, my frosting got really hard, almost like eating a cupcake with a piece of fudge on top. Is it supposed to be that way?
Allie says
Hi Gail – the frosting recipe is somewhat like the Brick Street Cake frosting and doesn’t lend itself as well to a cupcake as it does the cake. You might prefer a chocolate buttercream icing, and I may actually add in a recipe for that to the cupcake recipe so people can choose what they prefer. Thanks so much for the feedback, I truly appreciate it, helps me to improve. Have a super day!
Lindsay says
Just made these cupcakes and they turned out perfect. Using my own frosting. Thank you!
Allie says
Glad to hear it Lindsay!!!
Karen says
Do you think the cupcakes frosted could be frozen
Allie says
Hi Karen – I don’t think I would. I’d prob. make, freeze, then frost after they defrosted right before my event. (Then again I’m kind of a perfectionist.) 🙂 Many thanks for dropping by!
Deb says
Hi Allie, I’m not a blogger (don’t mean to make a blunder!) but had to ask a question about the cake and cupcakes…they look soooo good! When mixing the eggs and flour mixture is there a special procedure or do you just cream butter, beat in eggs then hand mix dry ingredients? I loved Hudson’s bus story, thanks for sharing. Many blessings to you and your family.
Allie says
Oh thank you so much Deb – it was great hearing from you. I love writing about Hudson and our little lightbulb moments along the way. And I hope you love these cupcakes. I don’t think you can go wrong with mixing these. I just mix in the remaining ingredients with my hand mixer on low speed, just until they are incorporated. Don’t over-mix, because it will make the cake tough, and don’t use a high speed because it will incorporate air into the batter and this is supposed to be a dense cake. You could also hand mix in the remaining ingredients and that is fine too. I’ve done it both ways. Have a beautiful weekend and thanks for dropping by!
CakenGifts.in Noida says
I did not know, how to make a cake but with the help of this recipe I made it successfully. It’s taste was marvellous!!!!!!!! I would like to recommend this cake to all my friends.
Susan says
Has anyone made these with gluten free flour? They look incredible!
Allie says
No one has commented here that they have, and I haven’t yet. But I’d love to try it. If you beat me to it, please let us know how they come out and what kind of gluten free flour you used, etc. Thanks for dropping by Susan, hope you have a great Christmas!
Mary says
I am learning to bake in convection ovens . My convection oven reduces temperature automatically by 25 degrees,so foo set in at 350 do cupcakes actually bake at325 in the convection?
Allie says
Hi Mary – no just bake them at 350° in your convection oven. This recipe already takes into account the temperature adjustment of a convection oven. Hope you love these cupcakes and Happy New Year!
Emma A says
I made this best chocolate cupcake ever. My family loved it. I accidentally added sugar with the dry ingredients. So what I did I melted the butter and mixed it in with the wet ingredients. It came out moist light and fluffy. Thank you for this amazing recipe.
Allie says
Hey that’s awesome to know Emma – thanks for the feedback and so glad they worked out, even with the creativity! That was a great idea! Did you enjoy them during the Superbowl? We were wishing we had something chocolate last night during the game. Have a super week!
Cheryl says
These look scrumptious! Did you use regular or Dutch cocoa? Also, do you have baking recommendations for mini cupcakes? Thatnk you so much.
Allie says
Hi Cheryl – thank you! I used regular Hershey’s cocoa in these cupcakes. I have not tried mini cupcakes with these yet, but I just got some silicone mini cupcake “pans”. So I will definitely be trying that soon. I will definitely come back and comment here about baking times etc. when I do, and will add it to the notes section of the recipe. Good luck, happy baking and would love to hear how it goes!
Cheryl says
Thank you for responding so quickly, and thank you for the info. I can’t wait to give these a go. 😊❤️
Jenna says
Do you think it’d be ok to half all the ingredients to make 12? Thanks!
Allie says
Hi Jenna – I haven’t done it but yes, I think it would be just fine. Hope you love ’em!
Jenna says
Thanks for the fast response! I love them, they’re perfect I have made them twice. Just have yet to try for 12. 🙂
Allie says
Great! 🙂
Kathryn says
I have not made this cake in a Very Long Time, and am debating whether I could pull off baking it in my Wilton 5-pan “Easy Layers” set. Any BRILLIANT ideas??
Allie says
Hi Kathryn – I’m not feeling particularly BRILLIANT today… lol. I didn’t even know what a Wilton 5-pan ‘Easy Layers’ set was. But now I do, I looked it up and it sounds like it would make an amazing layered cake. FYI – I did cut down the recipe of the Brick Street Chocolate Cake by 1/3 to make two dozen cupcakes. (Otherwise the cake recipe would have made three dozen.) So I’m not sure if you would use the Brick Street Cake recipe, which would make significantly more batter than the cupcake recipe… I think if it were me, I might make the cake recipe, being careful not to overfill the pans, and then if there was extra batter…. I’d bake a few cupcakes or a small loaf pan on the side. So there’s my brilliance for the day. Ha ha. Have a great weekend, so glad you dropped by, and if you would be so kind as to comment back here if you decide to make this in your special pan set, that would be great. Because I’m sure there are others out there who are interested to know if it works. And of course I’m curious too. Happy baking!
Kathryn says
Hi Allie,
The 5 pans combined hold the equivalent of 1 Cake mix, so if I cut the recipe in 1/2 I would have less chance of having too much batter. I purchased this pan set @ 60% off which was Great and probably should make a regular cake mix with it to calculate out just how much batter fits into each of them. Will keep you posted as things develop. Have a Great Weekend!
Julie says
I just made these and they were good, but mine were on the dry side and not dense like I was anticipating. I only cooked 15 mins and used convection. I am at high altitude, would that cause any problems?? Thanks for sharing, they were still a hit!
Juju says
Are the condiment cups 4 oz?
Allie says
Hi Juju – I’m away on vacation right now, so I can’t get to my condiment cups in the pantry. But if I had to guess, I’d say they are prob. 4 oz. When I get home next week, I’ll come back here and confirm that.
Jewel says
Hello! I would love to make this recipe. I’m new at baking and I wonder if baking cocoa as stated in your recipe is the same as unsweetened cocoa powder? Please reply! Thanks!
Allie says
Hi Jewel – yes, baking cocoa is unsweetened cocoa powder. I use Hershey’s brand and am happy with the flavor. I really hope you love this cake Jewel. Feel free to ask if you have any more questions. Happy baking!
Lesli says
These are seriously the most beautiful chocolate cupcakes I have ever made. They rose perfectly, stayed moist for days and taste AMAZING!! Thank you for sharing. Do you have an equally delicious white/wedding cupcake or Red Velvet cupcake recipe?
Adrienne says
Can I make this in a 9 x 13 pan?
Thanks!
Susan the Farm Quilter says
Your Hudson is one of “my kids” I used to teach. Sweet, funny, kind and just plain wonderful!! I retired a while ago and still miss “my kids”. I even learned sign language so I could help them learn to communicate and I still use the sign language to this day, even with people who can hear me perfectly!! You have a special blessing (and challenge) with Hudson. I’m so glad he has special people in his life like the bus driver and his helper. I know this post is over 2 years old, but Hudson just touched my heart.
Christina says
Hi …im so pleased u managed to make this into cupcakes as I’ve made the cake before and it’s delicious so thankyou…im toying on the idea of cream cheese frosting with these. Quick question do i store these cakes in a container and just frost these as and when I need to ? As i need them for 2 different days in a row and worried about them drying out?
Many thanks x
Kate says
I am super excited about making these gorgeous cupcakes for my bf’s bday. I have a dark Wilton cupcake pan & plan to use my new convection oven but not sure if I should turn the temperature down 25 deg. since it’s a dark pan like I do for a regular oven. Any suggestions? And hate to sound stupid but what is cake flour? Is it sold by the cake mixes at the grocery? I’ve never used it befoee! Thank you!!